E. B. Gannett (formerly-William Elgin)
Ship stats
Depth: To be announced
Coordinates: To be announced
Vessel Type: Two-masted schooner
Length: 62.8 feet
Breadth: 18.5 feet
Gross Tonnage: 44
Cargo: 40 tons of plaster
Built: 1864 by Gannett & Miners at Galloo Island, New York
Port of Registry: Sackets Harbor, New York
Owner at Loss: Perry et al. of Sackets Harbor, New York
Date Lost: August 27, 1870
Cause of Loss: Leaked
Loss of Life: None
Historical Background
This two-masted schooner was first discovered in 1997 by Ariel and Tim Shippee and documented in 2006 by Jim Kennard, Dan Scoville and Dennis Gerber. The wreck was initially identified as William Elgin, built in 1871, and which foundered in a storm on May 19, 1888 while bound from Oswego, New York to Belleville, Ontario while laden with coal.
The wreck was documented by NOAA and its partners at the Ocean Exploration Cooperative Institute in May 2025. Whereas William Elgin’s enrollment records provide the vessel's length between perpendiculars as 99 feet and beam as 23 feet, scaling measurements taken determined that this wreck was a significantly smaller vessel. While research is on-going to positively identify this vessel, evidence suggests that the wreck is likely E. B. Gannett.
The small two-masted schooner E. B. Gannett was built in 1864 by Gannett and Miner at Galloo Island, New York. The small schooner, measuring only 44 gross tons, was owned and operated out of Sackets Harbor, New York for the entirety of its career
On the evening of August 22, 1870, E. B. Gannett departed Oswego for Ogdensburg, New York, laden with 40 tons of plaster. While 12 miles off Oswego, crossing Mexico Bay, E. B. Gannett developed a leak and subsequently foundered. The crew escaped in the ship’s yawl, which they later landed safely at Nine-Mile Point, east of Oswego.
Wreck Site
Photomodel of E. B. Gannett, captured in May 2025 by NOAA and its partners at the Ocean Exploration Cooperative Institute. Photo: NOAA/OECI
Today, the remains of this schooner, believed to be E. B. Gannett, rest within Mexico Bay at depths nearing the upper limits of technical diving (330 feet/100 m).
The wreck rests upright and intact with both of its masts laying along the portside of the hull while the bowsprit remains in place and intact. The starboard anchor lies on the bottom, while the port anchor remains stowed along the port railing. The windlass and forecastle companionway hatch remain intact. Three hatches are present in the deck. Rather than the more typical free-standing aft cabin typical on most contemporary lake schooners, this wreck retains a raised quarterdeck, with the cabins located below the quarter deck. A drum-windlass type ship’s wheel is mounted to the quarterdeck.

