Neptune (ex-Farmer’s Daughter)
Ship stats
Depth: 400+ feet
Coordinates: To be announced
Vessel Type: Two-masted schooner
Length: 54.6 feet
Breadth: 16.6 feet
Tonnage (Burthen): 43.56
Cargo: General Merchandise
Port of Registry: Sackets Harbor, New York
Owner at Loss: J. C. Riggs
Date Lost: October 5, 1850
Cause of Loss: Storm
Loss of Life: 7 of 7
Historical Background
This schooner, dating to the first half of the 19th century, was discovered in July 2012 by researchers Daniel Scoville and Chris Koberstein, who conducted the first remotely-operated vehicle investigations of the wreck. At the time, the wreck was tentatively identified as the two-masted schooner Farmer’s Daughter which was built in 1816 at Sandy Creek, New York. Farmer’s Daughter was 58 feet 6 inches long, and had a beam of 16 feet 6 inches, and a 5-foot depth of hold, measuring 39.48 tons burthen. Farmer’s Daughter operated until at least 1829. Nothing certain is presently known concerning the Farmer's Daughter’s loss, but it was recorded as having gone missing with all hands sometime after 1829.
The wreck was documented by NOAA and its partners at the Ocean Exploration Cooperative Institute in May 2025. Subsequent research has called its identification as Farmer’s Daughter into question, due to inconsistencies with the vessel’s registered dimensions as well as the presence of a scroll figurehead on the wreck, whereas Farmer’s Daughter’s is recorded as having a plain stem. Furthermore, the presence of two Admiralty-pattern folding stock anchors on site, introduced in 1841, indicates a loss after 1841.
Ongoing research suggests that this wreck is more likely the two-masted schooner Neptune. Neptune was built at Three-Mile Bay, New York by Asa Wilcox in 1842. The small schooner measured 54.6 feet long, 16.6 feet in breadth with a depth of hold of 5.6 feet, measuring 43.59 tons burthen. Neptune was enrolled at the port of Sackets Harbor throughout its 8-year long career.
On October 5, 1850, Neptune departed Oswego, likely bound for Sackets Harbor, though its destination was not reported. While crossing the mouth of Mexico Bay, Neptune was caught in a fierce gale. The crew of the nearby schooner O.V. Brainard of Oswego later reported witnessing Neptune capsize and founder.
The crew of schooner D.W. Church, which had departed Oswego an hour after Neptune was likewise caught in the gale. While occupied in reefing their sails in preparation for the gale, sighted men in a boat, approximately a half mile downwind, off their starboard quarter. As they were engaged in reducing sail, they were unable to render assistance without risking their own vessel. The boat was sighted briefly several times but the Churchs soon lost sight of it. Nothing more was seen of Neptune’s crew of seven or the ship’s boat.
Wreck Site
A photomodel of the wreck captured in May 2025 by NOAA and its partners at the Ocean Exploration Cooperative Institute. Photo: NOAA/OECI
Today, Neptune lies in depths beyond the limits of technical diving (330 feet/100 meters) north-northeast of Oswego, New York.
The wreck remains entirely upright and intact.. The bow retains a scroll figurehead and an intact bowsprit. Both the foremast, mainmast and main topmast remain standing, the latter rising 66 feet above the deck. A handspike-operated windlass is located at the bow along with two iron folding-stock ‘Admiralty’ pattern anchors along its starboard side. Two hatches are present in the deck, each immediately behind the masts. The deck is enclosed by a low, open railing, rather than planked bulwarks which became common in later Great Lakes vessels. At the stern a small cabin remains intact forward of the tiller.

