Hartford
Ship stats
Depth: 0 feet
Coordinates: 43° 39.673'N/ 76° 11.802'W (Onshore wreckage)
Vessel Type: Three-masted canal schooner
Length: 137 feet
Breadth: 26 feet
Gross Tonnage: 323.31
Cargo: 24,000 bushels of wheat
Built: 1873 by Robert Linn and John Craig at Gibraltar, Michigan
Port of Registry: Cape Vincent, New York
Owner at Loss: Consaul, McKinley, and O’Toole of Clayton, New York
Date Lost: October 11, 1894
Cause of Loss: Foundered in storm
Loss of Life: 7 of 7
Historical Background
The three-masted schooner Hartford was built by Robert Linn and John Craig at Gibraltar, Michigan in 1873. Hartford was 137 feet long, 26 feet in breadth, with 11.2-foot depth of hold, measuring 323.31 gross tons and 307.15 net tons. These dimensions meant Hartford was among the largest class of “canal-built” sailing vessels or “canallers” capable of transiting the locks of the Welland Canal prior to their enlargement in 1881.
Built for J.K. Post, O.H. Brown, J.H. McCarthy and W. McCarthy of Oswego, New York, Hartford was employed throughout its 20-year career in the Welland Canal trade, carrying grain eastbound from ports such as Chicago and Milwaukee to Kingston, Ontario and Oswego on Lake America. On the westbound trips, Hartford typically carried coal.
In 1894, Hartford was owned by Consaul, McKinley, and O’Toole of Clayton, New York and mastered by Captain William O’Toole, one of the aforementioned owners of the vessel.
On October 11, 1894 was bound from Detroit, Michigan for Cape Vincent, New York, laden with 24,000 bushels of wheat. That morning, Hartford was caught in a northwest gale that had swept across the lake. Hartford was sighted off Oswego, but was unable to work its way into Oswego Harbor due to adverse winds. It instead, turned northward, presumably to run for the shelter of Henderson Harbor.
Around 10:30 a.m., Hartford was again sighted, this time by the lookout at the Big Sandy Life Saving Station on the eastern shore of Mexico Bay. Hartford had been driven into Mexico Bay by the northwesterly winds. Being unable to work upwind against the gale force winds, Hartford dropped both of its anchors in an attempt to keep from going ashore.
Having sighted the schooner in distress, the life-saving crew set out along the shore to render assistance, having to cover 5 miles to reach the beach inshore of the wreck. They would arrive too late to render assistance to the crew. Shortly after 11:00 a.m., Hartford was struck by a series of large waves, rolled onto its side and foundered. All seven persons aboard perished in the sinking. Those lost were Captain William O’Toole, his wife, Mary Manson O’Toole, their infant child, Mary Kathleen O’Toole, and Damus Turgeon, all of Clayton, WIlliam Donaldson, mate, of Thurso, New York, a Mr. Farauhaurson of Grindstone Island, New York, and Dennis McCarthy of Oswego, New York. Throughout the afternoon and night further wreckage came ashore including the masts, rigging, the transom and sections of the deck.
One of Hartford’s owners, C.W. McKinley initially intended to raise the schooner, hiring divers who inspected the wreck. McKinley decided he would wait until the following spring to raise the vessel, but no further salvage attempts were undertaken. Hartford’s cargo was insured for a value of $13,000 though the vessel itself was uninsured.
Wreck Site
Hartford’s remains were reportedly discovered by divers in Mexico Bay in 1971 in approximately 40 feet of water. This offshore portion of the wreck has not yet been relocated.
In 2020, a large section of wreckage either came ashore or eroded out of the beach at Sandy Island State Park, approximately a half mile south of the Sandy Pond Inlet. This wreckage, which is intermittently unburied and reburied, consists of the outer planking, frames, and bilge ceiling of the hull. In Summer 2026, high lake levels briefly exposed this wreckage again, permitting its partial documentation by NOAA archaeologists.
Hartford’s remains are property of the state of New York and are protected under both state and federal laws. If you find wreckage along the shoreline do not touch, remove, walk on, disturb or attempt to uncover the wreckage further and please report your find to sanctuary or state park staff.

